TutorChase logo
IB DP Biology Study Notes

1.5.5 Evidence for Virus Origins

Viruses, perplexing entities poised between the classifications of living and non-living, have long been subjects of intensive study and debate in the realm of biology. The narrative of their origins remains as compelling as it is complex.

Multiple Origins of Viruses

Instead of stemming from a singular evolutionary lineage, viruses appear to have multiple origins. This mosaic nature is primarily based on the vast diversity observed in their genetic material and structural characteristics.

Endogenous Retroviruses (ERVs)

  • Definition: ERVs are sequences in the DNA of cellular organisms that are closely related to retroviruses. They are considered relics of past retroviral infections.
  • Evidence from Genomes:
    • Several organisms, including humans, have ERV sequences in their genomes. This suggests that ancestors of these organisms were once infected by retroviruses.
    • Over time, these viral sequences became a permanent part of the host genome and were passed down through generations.

Comparative Analysis with Cellular Organisms

  • Genome Complexity:
    • Some viruses, like the pandoraviruses and mimiviruses, possess large and complex genomes that rival those of smaller bacteria. These genomes contain genes that are unfamiliar and don’t match any in current databases.
  • Ancient Origins:
    • The presence of unfamiliar genes might indicate that these viruses diverged from a common ancestor of cellular life forms very early in evolutionary history.
labelled structure of mimivirus.

Image courtesy of Labiotech.eu

Convergent Evolution

When organisms not closely related evolve similar traits or features, this process is termed convergent evolution. For viruses, this phenomenon is quite pronounced.

Divergent evolution vs convergent evolution.

Image courtesy of VectorMine

Enveloped vs. Non-enveloped Viruses

  • Independent Evolution:
    • Different viral families have independently evolved to possess an envelope – a lipid bilayer derived from the host. This feature facilitates infection by aiding in host cell entry.
  • Environmental Pressures:
    • The evolution of similar structures in unrelated viral families is likely driven by common environmental pressures, such as the need to escape host immune responses.

Viral Protein Structures

  • Function-driven Similarities:
    • Even when the underlying genetic sequences differ, viral proteins from distinct families can evolve to have analogous 3D structures. This is often because these proteins perform similar functions, necessitating a specific shape or configuration.
  • Host Cell Receptor Binding:
    • Proteins that bind to host cell receptors, facilitating viral entry, are prime examples. Despite diverse genetic origins, they may adopt similar configurations to fit the same or similar receptors on host cells.

Shared Genetic Code

It's pivotal to understand the shared genetic heritage between viruses and cellular life forms.

Codon Usage

  • Universal Code:
    • Despite their diversity, viruses predominantly use the same genetic code as their hosts. This universality underlines their shared evolutionary history.
  • Efficiency in Infection:
    • Adhering to the host's genetic code allows viruses to efficiently hijack the host’s machinery to translate viral mRNA into proteins.

Gene Homology

  • Shared Genes:
    • A number of viral genes display clear similarities to genes in cellular organisms. This homology suggests either a shared evolutionary past or frequent gene transfer events between viruses and their hosts.
  • Bacteriophages:
    • Phages often share genes with bacteria, underlining the close and ancient relationship between them. Some genes involved in DNA replication and repair in bacteriophages are particularly similar to bacterial counterparts.

Replication Mechanisms

  • Mirror Processes:
    • Viral replication processes, especially for DNA viruses, often mirror those of their host cells. This involves similar enzymes and mechanisms, with occasional variations to suit the virus’s unique needs.

Implications for Evolutionary Biology

Exploring virus origins and their shared genetic code with cellular life can reshape our understanding of life's evolutionary trajectory.

Mosaic Nature of Viral Genomes

  • Patchwork Genomes:
    • Viral genomes can often resemble patchworks, composed of genes seemingly borrowed from multiple sources. This highlights the extent of horizontal gene transfer, where genes are exchanged between species rather than being passed down vertically from parent to offspring.
  • Versatile Adaptation:
    • This adaptability enables viruses to rapidly adjust to new hosts or environmental conditions, underscoring their evolutionary prowess.

Insights into Early Life

  • Pre-cellular World:
    • Some theories suggest that viruses might represent remnants from a pre-cellular world, long before the first true cells emerged. If so, they offer tantalising glimpses into the early stages of life on Earth.
  • RNA World Hypothesis:
    • The RNA world hypothesis posits that life started as chains of RNA that had the dual ability to store information and catalyse chemical reactions. Some RNA viruses might be distant echoes of this ancient RNA world.
RNA world hypothesis vs central dogma.

Image courtesy of Testbook

FAQ

Yes, several theories postulate the role of viruses in early life evolution. One prominent theory is the "virus-first hypothesis," which suggests that viruses predated or coexisted with the first cellular life forms. Another intriguing theory is the "RNA world hypothesis," where life began as chains of RNA, which both stored genetic information and acted as catalysts. Some RNA viruses might be remnants of this ancient RNA-dominated world. While definitive proof is elusive, these theories highlight the potential significance of viruses in the early stages of life's evolutionary journey on Earth.

The presence of unfamiliar genes in viruses such as pandoraviruses is particularly intriguing. These genes don't match any in existing databases, suggesting they might represent ancient genetic sequences or entirely novel evolutionary paths. Their existence challenges the notion that all viruses are simply genetic "thieves," only carrying genes pilfered from their hosts. Instead, some of these viruses might have diverged from early cellular life forms or represent unique evolutionary lineages. Studying these unfamiliar genes can provide insights into the early evolution of life and highlight the potential depths of undiscovered genetic diversity on Earth.

Understanding viral replication mechanisms offers insights into their co-evolution with host cells. Many viruses use replication processes that mirror those of their host cells, suggesting a deep evolutionary connection. For DNA viruses, the replication often involves similar enzymes and mechanisms, albeit tailored to the virus's requirements. Such similarities indicate either a shared evolutionary history or a long-standing interaction, where viruses and hosts have influenced each other's evolutionary trajectories. Studying these mechanisms can provide clues about the origins of certain cellular processes and shed light on how viruses have adapted to exploit their hosts effectively.

The mosaic or patchwork nature of many viral genomes indicates that they often contain genes from diverse sources. This patchwork composition supports the concept of horizontal gene transfer (HGT), where genes are transferred between organisms in ways other than traditional reproduction. Viruses can pick up genes from one host and transfer them to another, acting as vectors for HGT. This can lead to rapid evolutionary changes and can also blur the lines of genetic ancestry, making the evolutionary history of organisms more intricate and interconnected than previously thought.

Viruses pose a unique challenge when trying to fit them into the conventional tree of life, mainly because they lack many of the traits typically associated with living organisms, such as cellular structure and metabolism. However, due to their genetic material and their interactions with living hosts, they can't be entirely excluded. Some biologists suggest that viruses might be placed on their own unique branches, representing their diverse evolutionary origins. Others posit that they might represent ancient forms of life, predating the divergence of current cellular life forms. Regardless, while they might not fit neatly into established categories, their evolutionary connections with cellular life are undeniable.

Practice Questions

Describe the concept of convergent evolution in the context of viruses, and provide an example.

Convergent evolution refers to the process by which organisms not closely related independently evolve similar traits or features due to facing analogous environmental pressures or fulfilling similar ecological roles. In the realm of viruses, this phenomenon can be observed in the evolution of structures or functional proteins. A prime example is the independent evolution of the envelope in various viral families. Despite being unrelated, several viruses have developed a lipid bilayer envelope, derived from the host cell, which assists in the infection process by facilitating entry into host cells. This similarity has likely evolved in response to common challenges, such as evading host immune responses.

Discuss the significance of endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) in understanding the evolutionary relationship between viruses and their hosts.

Endogenous retroviruses (ERVs) are sequences within the DNA of cellular organisms that resemble retroviruses. These sequences are considered to be remnants of past retroviral infections, indicating that the ancestors of modern-day organisms were once hosts to these retroviruses. Over evolutionary time scales, these viral sequences became integrated into the host genome and have been inherited across successive generations. The presence of ERVs provides compelling evidence of the long-standing interactions between viruses and their hosts. Furthermore, the study of ERVs offers invaluable insights into the co-evolutionary dynamics between hosts and viruses, highlighting the extensive genetic interplay and shared evolutionary history between them.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
Your details
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email