TutorChase logo
IB DP History Study Notes

20.9.5 Japan Meiji Restoration and 1889 Constitution

The Meiji Restoration, beginning in 1868, marked a pivotal moment in Japanese history, initiating a period of rapid modernisation and political change. This era saw the introduction of the 1889 Constitution, which laid the groundwork for Japan's transformation into a modern state.

Reasons for the Meiji Restoration

Political and Social Unrest

  • Decline of Tokugawa Shogunate: The Tokugawa Shogunate, ruling since 1603, faced eroding authority, primarily due to its inability to handle foreign threats effectively and maintain internal stability.
  • Western Influence and Pressure: The forced opening of Japan to foreign trade by Commodore Perry's arrival in 1853 exposed the Shogunate's weaknesses and ignited internal criticism, especially among the samurai and regional lords.
  • Samurai and Daimyo Discontent: Many samurai and daimyo were disgruntled by the Shogunate's power monopoly, its handling of foreign threats, and the perceived erosion of their status and privileges.

Economic Challenges

  • Shogunate's Financial Burden: The Tokugawa regime faced severe financial strain due to the cost of maintaining a large bureaucratic and military apparatus, leading to increased taxation and peasant unrest.
  • Agricultural Distress: Economic hardship in rural areas, exacerbated by poor harvests and high taxes, led to widespread dissatisfaction and occasional rebellions against the Shogunate.

Ideological Shift

  • Sonno Joi Movement: The "revere the Emperor, expel the barbarians" movement gained traction, advocating for the restoration of imperial rule and resistance against foreign influence.
  • Imperial Restoration Ideals: Calls for the restoration of the Emperor's power grew louder, with many seeing this as a means to unify and strengthen Japan against foreign threats.

The 1889 Constitution

Formation and Influences

  • Western Constitutional Models: The Meiji leaders, influenced by Western political systems, particularly the Prussian model, sought to draft a constitution to establish a modern, centralised state.
  • Imperial Sanction: The Constitution was presented as a gift from the Emperor, reinforcing the restored imperial authority and the continuity of the imperial tradition.

Constitutional Provisions

  • Bicameral Legislature: The Constitution established a two-house Imperial Diet, consisting of an elected House of Representatives and an appointed House of Peers.
  • Executive Authority: While the Emperor retained supreme executive power, including control over the military and foreign policy, the Constitution allowed for the establishment of a cabinet and prime minister.
  • Civil Rights and Liberties: The Constitution included provisions for basic civil rights, though these were often subject to government regulation and limitations.

Significance and Impact

  • Constitutional Monarchy: The 1889 Constitution marked Japan's transition to a constitutional monarchy, balancing modern governance with traditional imperial authority.
  • Modernisation and Centralisation: It facilitated Japan's rapid modernisation and centralisation, essential for its transformation into a global power.
  • Political and Legal Reforms: The Constitution catalysed political and legal reforms, laying the foundation for Japan's modern administrative and legal systems.

Meiji Era Social and Economic Transformations

Educational and Social Reforms

  • National Education System: The establishment of a comprehensive education system was crucial for promoting literacy, civic duty, and the values of the new state.
  • Social Structure Overhaul: The class system was reformed, abolishing the feudal class hierarchy and creating a more egalitarian society.

Economic Modernisation

  • Industrialisation and Infrastructure: State-led industrialisation initiatives, including building railways and factories, transformed Japan's economic landscape.
  • International Trade and Relations: Japan's active engagement in international trade signalled its emergence as an important economic player.

Challenges and Criticisms of the Meiji Restoration and Constitution

Democratic Limitations

  • Restricted Suffrage: The Constitution allowed only a small, primarily wealthy segment of the population to vote, limiting the extent of democratic participation.
  • Authoritarian Elements: Despite the establishment of a parliamentary system, the Emperor's authority remained largely unchallenged, and the government retained significant control over individual rights.

Social and Economic Disruptions

  • Impact on Traditional Classes: The rapid modernisation and industrialisation led to the displacement of the samurai class and significant changes in rural communities.
  • Urbanisation and Labour Issues: Urbanisation brought challenges, including poor working conditions in factories and the growth of urban poverty.

The Meiji Restoration and the establishment of the 1889 Constitution signify a profound transformation in Japan's history. This era is characterised by the balancing act between modernisation and maintaining traditional Japanese values, which played a crucial role in shaping Japan's trajectory towards becoming a major global power. The Meiji era's legacy is complex, marked by significant achievements in modernisation and state-building, as well as challenges in terms of democratic development and social change.

FAQ

The Meiji government implemented several key economic policies to modernise Japan. Central to these was the promotion of industrialisation, with the state playing a major role in establishing and subsidising key industries, such as textiles, shipbuilding, and steel manufacturing. The government also invested heavily in infrastructure development, including railways, telegraph lines, and port facilities, to facilitate industrial and commercial growth. Financial reforms were significant, including the establishment of a modern banking system, the adoption of a new currency, and the creation of a stock exchange. Land tax reforms were another critical measure, converting traditional rice tax payments into a fixed money tax, which helped stabilise government revenue and promote commercial farming. These policies collectively transformed Japan's economic landscape, driving rapid industrialisation and economic growth.

The Meiji Restoration brought about significant but complex changes for women in Japanese society. Traditionally, women had a subordinate status, and this largely continued during the Meiji era. However, the introduction of a modern education system provided some women with access to education, albeit with a curriculum focused on preparing them for domestic roles and duties as "good wives and wise mothers." While this reinforced traditional gender roles, education also opened up new opportunities for women, albeit limited, in the workforce, particularly in the burgeoning textile industry. The legal status of women remained restrictive, with civil codes reinforcing patriarchal family structures. Overall, while there were some advancements in women's education, the Meiji era saw the reinforcement of traditional gender roles within a modernising society.

The Meiji Restoration had profound cultural impacts on Japanese society. The government encouraged fukoku kyohei (rich country, strong military) and sought to modernise and westernise various aspects of Japanese culture. This led to the adoption of Western dress and architectural styles among the elite and in government institutions. In education, there was a shift towards Western learning and science, though with an emphasis on maintaining Japanese values. The arts also saw a blending of Western and traditional Japanese styles. However, there was also a reactionary movement that sought to preserve traditional Japanese culture, leading to a complex interplay between Westernisation and the reaffirmation of Japanese traditions. This period set the stage for Japan's unique cultural identity, balancing modernity and tradition.

The Samurai class, once the military elite of feudal Japan, experienced a dramatic transformation during the Meiji Restoration. With the dismantling of the feudal system, the samurai lost their traditional status and privileges, including their right to bear arms and their stipends from the government. Many samurai initially resisted the changes, leading to rebellions like the Satsuma Rebellion in 1877. However, as the Restoration progressed, numerous samurai adapted to the new order. They became instrumental in driving forward the reforms, with many taking up administrative roles in the new government or contributing to modernising efforts in education, military, and industry. Their skills, discipline, and education made them valuable assets in Japan's transition to a modern state.

The Meiji Restoration significantly transformed Japan's foreign relations and diplomacy. Prior to the Restoration, Japan had been isolated, practising a policy of sakoku (closed country). However, the Meiji government aggressively pursued a path of international engagement. This shift was driven by the desire to avoid the fate of other Asian countries that had fallen victim to Western imperialism. Japan sought to learn from Western powers, sending delegations abroad, and adopted Western diplomatic practices. This led to the renegotiation of unequal treaties imposed by Western powers, a significant step in establishing Japan as a sovereign and equal player in international affairs. Japan's victory in the Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895) further asserted its diplomatic and military prowess, marking its emergence as a significant regional power.

Practice Questions

Evaluate the impact of the Meiji Restoration on Japan's political structure.

The Meiji Restoration profoundly transformed Japan's political structure, replacing the feudal Tokugawa Shogunate with a centralised, constitutional monarchy under the Emperor. This shift centralised power and unified the nation, paving the way for modern governance. The introduction of the 1889 Constitution was pivotal, creating a bicameral legislature and delineating the powers of the Emperor and government. It marked a transition to a more systematic and modern political framework, though it retained authoritarian elements. Overall, the Meiji Restoration's impact on Japan's political structure was transformative, setting the foundation for its emergence as a modern state.

Discuss the significance of the 1889 Constitution in Japan's process of modernisation.

The 1889 Constitution was a cornerstone in Japan's modernisation process, symbolising a shift from feudal governance to a modern state system. It laid the groundwork for political, legal, and social reforms essential for modernisation. By establishing a constitutional monarchy and a bicameral legislature, it introduced elements of Western political systems, while maintaining traditional Japanese imperial authority. The Constitution also spurred advancements in civil services, education, and legal systems, integral to Japan's modernisation. Its significance lies in balancing Western influences with Japanese traditions, thus facilitating a unique path of modernisation that propelled Japan onto the global stage.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
About yourself
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email