TutorChase logo
IB DP History Study Notes

20.8.5 Constitutional Developments and National Identity in Oceania (1788–1919)

This period encapsulates the emergence of a unified national identity and significant constitutional milestones in Oceania, particularly in Australia and New Zealand. Students will explore the formative events that shaped the political landscapes of these nations.

The Federation Movement

In the late 19th century, the movement to federate the Australian colonies gained momentum, culminating in the creation of the Commonwealth of Australia.

  • Economic and Defence Drivers: Economic factors, such as trade, tariffs, and intercolonial railway systems, alongside defence concerns, were key motivators for federation.
  • The 1891 Convention: Delegates from each colony met in Sydney, drafting a constitution that proposed the establishment of a federal council and a national parliament.
  • People’s Conventions and Referendums: The 1890s saw further conventions driven by the people rather than the colonial governments, leading to a series of referendums in which the public voted in favour of federation.

Growth of National Identity

The federation period also saw the rise of a collective Australian identity, which was expressed through various cultural forms.

  • Literary Flourishing: The 'Bulletin School' of writers, including Banjo Paterson and Henry Lawson, celebrated rural life and the Australian bush, contrasting it with European landscapes.
  • Anzac Legend: The shared sacrifices of Australian and New Zealand Army Corps (ANZAC) during World War I were central to national identity, with Gallipoli becoming a symbol of bravery and mateship.

National Australasian Conventions

The conventions of the 1890s were crucial in the drafting of the Australian Constitution.

  • 1897–1898 Conventions: These were marked by intense negotiations over the balance of power between the Commonwealth and the states, resulting in a draft constitution.
  • Constitutional Approval: The final draft was approved by the colonial parliaments and the British Parliament, leading to the enactment of the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act in 1900.

Achievement of Dominion Status

Dominion status was a testament to the nations' ability to govern themselves while remaining within the British Empire.

Australia (1901)

  • Federation Celebrations: The federation was officially proclaimed in Centennial Park, Sydney, with a grand public ceremony attended by thousands.
  • Structural Framework: The Constitution provided for a Governor-General, representing the British monarch, and outlined the responsibilities of the federal government and states.

New Zealand (1907)

  • Separate Path: Unlike Australia, New Zealand did not join the federation, preferring to negotiate its own status within the Empire.
  • Dominion Day: New Zealand's shift from colony to dominion was marked by celebrations and a sense of matured national pride.

Constitutional Developments

The early 20th century was a period of significant constitutional activity for Australia and New Zealand.

  • Legislative Independence: The Statute of Westminster in 1931 granted full legislative independence, but it was not adopted by Australia and New Zealand until 1942 and 1947 respectively.
  • Continual Reform: Throughout the 20th century, both nations amended their constitutions and developed their legal systems to better reflect their independent national identities.

Conclusion

The federation of Australia and the dominion status of New Zealand were milestones that not only shaped the political landscape but also fostered a sense of national identity. These constitutional developments, amid global and imperial contexts, signified the nations' transitions from colonial states to self-determined members of the Commonwealth.

The detailed notes would delve deeper into each of these sections, elaborating on the economic, social, and political nuances of the federation movement and the factors contributing to the growth of national identity. It would also describe the specific proceedings and outcomes of the National Australasian Conventions and the various paths taken by Australia and New Zealand to achieve dominion status. Additionally, the notes would outline the subsequent constitutional developments that furthered the political independence of both nations. Throughout, key terms and concepts would be highlighted in bold to assist students in identifying the most important elements for their studies.

FAQ

Although the Treaty of Versailles is often associated with the end of World War I and the peace terms with Germany, it also had implications for the status of Australia and New Zealand within the British Empire. By being signatories to the Treaty and members of the League of Nations in their own right, both nations affirmed their status as independent actors on the world stage, separate from Britain. This marked a significant step in their evolving national identities and independence, reinforcing their status as dominions and affirming their autonomy in international affairs.

The concept of 'mateship' is central to the Australian national identity and is often traced back to the ANZAC legend. Originating from the experiences of Australian soldiers during World War I, particularly at Gallipoli, 'mateship' embodies the qualities of loyalty, equality, camaraderie, and resilience. These soldiers, facing adversity in foreign lands, relied on each other for survival, forming bonds that transcended social and economic divisions. This ideal became a defining characteristic of the national psyche, representing a unique Australian spirit that was egalitarian and anti-authoritarian, reflecting the country's values as it stepped onto the world stage as a federation.

The gold rushes of the 1850s to the 1890s had a significant impact on the push for federation in Australia. They attracted a substantial influx of immigrants, leading to a population boom and a more diverse society. The wealth generated from gold mining propelled economic growth and increased the colonies' self-confidence, contributing to a growing sense of Australian identity separate from Britain. The need to manage the wealth and the population effectively across colonial borders prompted calls for a unified economic and political system, thus furthering the cause of federation.

Key factors leading to the successful federation of Australian colonies included the desire for a unified defence system against possible foreign threats, the need to manage intercolonial trade with uniform tariffs, and the aspiration to develop a cohesive national infrastructure, including transport and communication systems. Moreover, the social and political desire to foster a united Australian identity played a significant role. The spread of nationalism, bolstered by the economic and defence benefits, convinced many colonists that federation was not only beneficial but also necessary for the colonies' prosperity and security.

The labour movement played a pivotal role in the federation of Australia and the development of its national identity. Workers' rights became a significant issue due to the harsh conditions faced by the working class, particularly in the burgeoning industries and mining sectors. The movement's push for better conditions, including fair wages and reasonable working hours, was a unifying force that crossed colonial borders. It contributed to the social cohesion and egalitarian spirit that characterised the emerging national identity. The labour movement's influence ensured that social reform and worker protections were central issues in the debates leading to federation.

Practice Questions

Evaluate the significance of the National Australasian Conventions in the development of the Australian Constitution.

The National Australasian Conventions were instrumental in the development of the Australian Constitution. They provided a forum for delegates from the colonies to discuss and negotiate the terms of federation, ensuring that the constitution was representative of the views and interests of the colonies involved. These conventions led to the drafting of a constitution that balanced the powers of the Commonwealth and the states, which was a crucial factor in the successful federation of Australia. The conventions exemplified the collaborative effort to achieve a unified nation, making them a significant milestone in Australia's constitutional history.

Discuss the impact of achieving dominion status on New Zealand's national identity.

Achieving dominion status had a profound impact on New Zealand's national identity, marking its transition from a British colony to a self-governing nation within the British Empire. This change was symbolic of New Zealand's maturity and growing independence, fostering a sense of pride and distinctiveness from both Britain and Australia. Dominion status allowed New Zealand to control its internal affairs, contributing to a burgeoning national consciousness and reinforcing its identity on the world stage. This shift was a crucial step in New Zealand's journey towards full sovereignty and played a key role in shaping its national identity.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
About yourself
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email