TutorChase logo
IB DP History Study Notes

19.4.5 The Great Awakening c1720–c1760

The Great Awakening stands as a significant religious movement that reshaped the social and political fabric of the Americas in the 18th century. This era was characterised by a series of revivals that implanted a newfound evangelical zeal within the existing religious structures, leading to profound changes in the colonies.

Social Impact of the Great Awakening

Transformation of Religious Practices and Community Dynamics

  • Traditional ecclesiastical authority was challenged as individuals sought a more direct and emotional connection with God. This change can be compared to earlier shifts within the Catholic Church in the 16th century.
  • Churches no longer held a monopoly on worship; revival meetings were often held outdoors and attracted large gatherings, reinforcing a community bond through collective spiritual experiences.

Shift Toward Personal Piety and Self-Governance in Faith

  • The Great Awakening placed a strong emphasis on personal conversion experiences, the assurance of salvation, and the reading of Scriptures.
  • This period democratised religious knowledge, reducing the control of clergy and making religion a personal responsibility. Similar themes of religious and cultural interaction can be seen in the spread of Islam and Christianity in Africa.

Impact on Education and Literary Rates

  • New educational institutions like Princeton and Dartmouth College were established to promote the teachings of the revival.
  • Literacy rates increased as the populace sought to read religious texts, with the Bible becoming a widely owned and read book in the colonies.

Political Impact of the Great Awakening

Erosion of Established Church and State Relationships

  • The challenge to established churches mirrored a challenge to the entrenched civil authorities, especially where church and state were interlinked. This erosion of traditional structures can be likened to the impact of the French Revolution.
  • This laid a subtle groundwork for questioning other forms of authority, including the British monarchy and its colonial governance.

Fostering of American Identity and Unity

  • Revivalism provided a shared cultural and spiritual experience, transcending colonial boundaries and helping to shape a collective American consciousness.
  • The rapid spread of revivalist ideas and the formation of networks among believers contributed to an early sense of national unity among the American colonies.

Key Figures of the Great Awakening

George Whitefield: The Itinerant Preacher

  • Whitefield's dramatic and emotional preaching style captured the hearts of countless colonists, making him a celebrity-like figure of the era. His efforts in spreading revivalism can be compared to the influence of enlightened despots in Europe.
  • He is credited with spreading the revival across the colonies, using cross-colonial tours and the media to propagate his message.

Jonathan Edwards: The Theological Mind

  • Jonathan Edwards is renowned for his articulate sermons and treatises that provided a rich, intellectual foundation for the Awakening's emotional fervour.
  • His emphasis on sincere religious experience and predestination galvanised many to seek a personal relationship with God.

Movements and Denominations Stemming from the Great Awakening

Birth and Growth of New Denominations

  • The Awakening's influence led to the rapid expansion of Baptists and Methodists, who stressed a personal approach to religion.
  • These groups broke away from hierarchical and state-controlled church structures, favouring a more egalitarian and democratic church organisation. This schism is reminiscent of the historical interactions and adaptations seen in indigenous belief systems and Christianity.

Old Lights vs. New Lights: A Theological Schism

  • 'Old Lights' adherents favoured traditional, rational Christianity and were critical of the emotionalism and the 'disorderly' nature of revivals.
  • 'New Lights', conversely, embraced the revivalist ideology and its dynamic, transformative societal role.

Women's Increased Religious Participation

  • The revivals often afforded women a more active public role in religious affairs than traditionally permitted, contributing to early feminist undercurrents in the colonies.

Cultural Interactions and Religious Syncretism

Christianity's Influence on Enslaved Africans and Indigenous Peoples

  • Christianity was often adopted by enslaved Africans, who combined it with their own spiritual beliefs, creating syncretic religions.
  • Indigenous Americans similarly engaged with Christianity, leading to a unique blend of Christian and native beliefs, practices, and communities.

Proliferation of Religious Literature

  • The demand for printed sermons, religious tracts, and theological discourse led to a burgeoning of religious literature, which played a crucial role in the spread of revivalist ideas.

Enduring Effects of the Great Awakening

The Legacy of Religious Pluralism

  • The legacy of the Great Awakening contributed to a religiously plural society in America, paving the way for the freedom of religion enshrined in the Bill of Rights.
  • The religious diversity initiated by the Awakening is a hallmark of American society, which continues to be seen in the present day.

The Awakening as a Precursor to Revolutionary Ideals

  • The movement's promotion of egalitarianism and individualism laid philosophical seeds for the American Revolution and the democratic principles that would later define the nation.

In examining the lasting impact of the Great Awakening, it becomes clear that its influence extended far beyond the spiritual realm. It disrupted established religious order, altered the socio-political landscape, and fostered a burgeoning American identity. By encouraging a sense of independence and challenging the status quo, the Great Awakening not only redefined the concept of religious authority but also played a subtle, yet powerful, role in setting the stage for the revolutionary developments that would soon follow. Through its vibrant itinerant preachers, its radical movements, and its powerful sermons, the Awakening left an indelible mark on the American colonies, sowing the seeds of modernity in thought, governance, and community life.

FAQ

The economic repercussions of the Great Awakening were less direct than the social and political impacts but were nonetheless significant. The movement prompted the growth of a transatlantic print culture as demand for religious materials surged, leading to an expansion of the printing and publishing industries. It also stimulated the founding of new institutions like colleges, which required financial support and thereby contributed to local economies. Moreover, the breakdown of old parish structures due to the rise of new denominations led to diversification in how churches were funded, often through voluntary contributions, which had subtle implications for economic models of community support and charity.

The Great Awakening prefigured the American Revolution by introducing a climate of questioning authority and emphasising individual judgment. The movement's challenge to religious authority mirrored and, in some ways, catalysed challenges to secular authority. It preached that salvation and truth were not mediated by institutions but were the province of individual conscience, a principle easily transposed to political thought. This climate of individualism and scepticism of traditional hierarchies nurtured an environment ripe for revolutionary ideas, where the concept of personal liberty could extend from the religious to the political sphere, paving the way for resistance against British colonial rule.

While the Great Awakening did not directly challenge the institution of slavery, its emphasis on spiritual equality and the shared experience of conversion provided a discourse through which slaves and critics of slavery could question the moral legitimacy of slavery. Some preachers, like George Whitefield, though owning slaves themselves, condemned the cruelty of slave owners and called for a more humane treatment of the enslaved. Furthermore, the evangelical movement spread to African slaves, leading to the creation of a distinctive African-American Christianity that was a source of community, solace, and eventually, resistance. However, the overall structure of slavery remained largely intact during and immediately after the Awakening.

The Great Awakening had a subtle yet significant effect on the roles of women in colonial society. While not uniformly transformative, the revivalist movement offered women greater participation in public religious life than was traditionally permissible. Women were active in revival meetings, often as part of the audience and occasionally as preachers, a departure from their conventional domestic confines. The movement's emphasis on personal spiritual experience over formal theological training diminished the gender barrier to spiritual leadership. This religious empowerment, while not directly challenging the patriarchy, planted seeds for future questions about women's roles both in the church and society.

The Great Awakening influenced the education of children by linking religious instruction with broader education imperatives. Before the Awakening, education was primarily the purview of wealthy families and certain religious sects. The movement's emphasis on reading the Bible and interpreting scripture for oneself led to a greater emphasis on literacy and education across all classes. Educational institutions, such as Princeton and Dartmouth, were founded to train clergy in the evangelical vein, broadening the educational opportunities. Moreover, these institutions began to embrace a wider curriculum over time, which reflected the awakening's spirit of enquiry and individual interpretation.

Practice Questions

Evaluate the extent to which the Great Awakening contributed to the development of a distinct American identity in the 18th century.

The Great Awakening was instrumental in fostering a distinct American identity by transcending colonial boundaries through shared evangelical experiences. The revivals facilitated a collective identity that superseded regional diversities, manifesting in a common language of spiritual renewal and individual liberty. This commonality of purpose and newfound unity among the colonies provided the ideological groundwork that facilitated a sense of American uniqueness, pivotal for the eventual struggle for independence. Thus, the Great Awakening’s contribution was significant as it provided not just a religious, but also a cultural and ideological cohesion that was distinctly American.

Analyse the role played by key figures such as George Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards in shaping the social dynamics of the British colonies during the Great Awakening.

George Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards were central to shaping the social dynamics of the British colonies during the Great Awakening. Whitefield's charismatic oratory and media savvy projected the Awakening across colonial society, breaking down the established social order by appealing to a broad audience beyond conventional congregations. Jonathan Edwards' intellectual sermons provided a theological foundation that legitimised the emotional experiences of the revivals, thereby validating a new social norm of individual religious introspection and piety. Together, they disrupted traditional ecclesiastical authority, democratised religious participation, and altered the colonies' social fabric by promoting a personal, emotive religious practice.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
About yourself
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email