TutorChase logo
CIE A-Level Psychology Notes

6.4.4 Behavioural Therapy for Anxiety Disorders

Behavioural therapy, a core method in treating anxiety disorders, employs techniques based on the theory that maladaptive behaviours, including excessive fear responses, can be unlearned or modified through systematic approaches. Among these, systematic desensitisation is notably effective in managing fear-related disorders.

Systematic Desensitisation: Comprehensive Insight

Developed in the 1950s by Joseph Wolpe, systematic desensitisation is a behavioural therapy rooted in classical conditioning principles. It's particularly effective in treating phobias, a common type of fear-related disorder.

Core Components

  • Exposure Therapy: It involves controlled exposure to the fear source, aiming to gradually reduce the fear response.
  • Relaxation Techniques: Patients learn methods such as deep breathing, muscle relaxation, or meditation to manage anxiety.
  • Anxiety Hierarchy Creation: An essential step where patients list their fears in order of intensity, from the least to the most anxiety-provoking.

Application in Fear-Related Disorders

  • Step-by-Step Approach: Starts with situations that invoke minimal anxiety, progressively advancing to more frightening scenarios.
  • Safe Setting: The therapy is conducted in a safe, controlled environment, often starting in imagination before real-life applications.
  • Empowering the Patient: Patients learn to associate relaxation, rather than anxiety, with the feared stimuli.

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Behavioural Therapies

Behavioural therapies like systematic desensitisation are recognised for their effectiveness in treating anxiety disorders, but their efficacy can vary based on several factors.

Success Rates and Advantages

  • Specific Phobia Treatment: Particularly successful in treating specific phobias, with many patients showing significant improvement.
  • Long-lasting Effects: Offers more enduring relief compared to pharmacotherapy, as it targets the root behavioural causes.

Influencing Factors

  • Patient Engagement: Success hinges on the patient’s active involvement and adherence to therapy.
  • Therapist's Proficiency: The therapist's experience and skill play a vital role in the therapy's success.
  • Complexity of Disorder: More effective for straightforward cases; complex anxiety disorders might require a multi-faceted approach.

Methodological Approaches in Behavioural Therapies

The systematic and structured nature of behavioural therapies is key to their effectiveness in treating anxiety disorders.

Techniques and Strategies

  • Exposure-Based Methods: These involve direct exposure to the fear source in a controlled setting.
  • Relaxation and Stress-Management Training: Techniques like deep breathing and progressive muscle relaxation are taught.
  • Cognitive Approaches: Aims to identify and alter negative thought patterns that contribute to anxiety.

Planning and Implementation

  • Tailored Treatment Plans: Therapy is customised to each patient's unique fears and anxiety levels.
  • Monitoring and Adjustment: Regular assessment of progress with adjustments to the treatment plan as needed.
  • Homework Assignments: Tasks assigned to patients for practice outside of therapy sessions enhance the treatment's effectiveness.

Considerations and Challenges

While behavioural therapy is highly valued, understanding its limitations and ethical implications is crucial for effective and responsible application.

Potential Limitations

  • Varied Efficacy: Not universally effective for all anxiety disorders; success rates can vary.
  • Risk of Relapse: Some patients might experience a recurrence of fear or anxiety over time.
  • Dependency on Patient Participation: Less effective for those who are unmotivated or resistant to therapy.

Ethical and Professional Considerations

  • Informed Consent: Ensuring patients are fully aware of the therapy process and potential risks.
  • Minimising Harm: Therapy should not exacerbate the patient's anxiety or fear.
  • Confidentiality Assurance: A fundamental aspect, maintaining the privacy of patient information.

FAQ

The success of behavioural therapy for anxiety disorders is typically measured through a combination of subjective and objective methods. Subjectively, patients are often asked to report changes in their feelings of anxiety, fear, and overall well-being throughout the course of the therapy. This can be done through self-report scales, like the Fear Survey Schedule or the Beck Anxiety Inventory, where patients rate their symptoms. Objectively, therapists might observe and record the patient's responses during therapy sessions, noting changes in physical symptoms of anxiety (such as heart rate or sweating) and behavioural responses to exposure tasks. Additionally, the achievement of specific treatment goals, like facing a particular feared situation without excessive anxiety, is a crucial measure of success. In some cases, feedback from family members or others close to the patient can also be considered to gauge improvements in the patient's everyday life. A combination of these assessment methods provides a comprehensive picture of the therapy's effectiveness.

Relaxation techniques are a fundamental component of systematic desensitisation, serving to counteract the anxiety response during exposure to feared stimuli. These techniques help in activating the body's natural relaxation response, a state of rest that counterbalances the fight or flight response triggered by fear and anxiety. They include deep breathing exercises, progressive muscle relaxation, guided imagery, and mindfulness meditation. During the therapy, patients are first taught these techniques in a calm and controlled environment. The therapist guides the patient through exercises that focus on relaxing different muscle groups and controlling breathing. This training helps patients in recognising and controlling their physical responses to anxiety. As therapy progresses, these relaxation techniques are employed during exposure to the feared object or situation. By practicing relaxation in the face of fear, patients gradually learn to dissociate the feared stimuli from the anxiety response, effectively reducing their phobic reaction over time. This not only helps during therapy sessions but also equips patients with skills they can use in real-life situations outside of therapy.

When using behavioural therapy for treating children with anxiety disorders, several ethical considerations must be addressed. Firstly, informed consent is essential. For children, this means obtaining consent from parents or guardians, as well as assent from the child, ensuring they understand the therapy and are comfortable with it. Secondly, the therapy must be age-appropriate and sensitive to the developmental stage of the child. Techniques and materials used should be suitable for the child's cognitive and emotional maturity level. Thirdly, ensuring the child's safety and well-being throughout the therapy process is paramount. The therapy should not induce excessive distress or fear. Additionally, confidentiality must be maintained, while also ensuring that parents or guardians are adequately informed about the child's progress and any issues that arise. Finally, therapists must be vigilant about the power dynamics in therapist-child relationships and maintain a supportive, respectful, and non-coercive environment. Ethical practice in treating children not only involves adherence to these principles but also requires therapists to stay updated with the latest research and guidelines pertaining to child psychology and therapy.

Behavioural therapy can be effectively combined with other treatment methods for anxiety disorders, creating a more comprehensive approach. This is known as a multimodal treatment strategy. For instance, combining behavioural therapy with cognitive therapy forms Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy (CBT), which addresses both the behavioural and cognitive patterns contributing to the anxiety disorder. CBT is particularly effective because it not only helps patients to manage their fear response through behavioural techniques like systematic desensitisation but also helps in altering negative thought patterns associated with the anxiety. Furthermore, in some cases, behavioural therapy is combined with pharmacotherapy, especially in severe anxiety disorders. Medications like SSRIs (Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors) can reduce overall anxiety levels, making it easier for patients to engage in behavioural therapy. However, the choice to combine therapies should be based on individual patient needs, the severity of the disorder, and the specific type of anxiety disorder being treated. A tailored approach, often decided upon by a mental health professional, ensures that patients receive the most effective and personalised treatment.

Systematic desensitisation is a specific type of exposure therapy designed to reduce fear and anxiety responses. It differs from other exposure therapies in its structured and gradual approach. Unlike other methods, such as flooding, which involves immediate and intense exposure to the feared object or situation, systematic desensitisation progresses gradually. It begins with teaching relaxation techniques to the patient, which are then employed during the exposure process. This gradual exposure starts from the least frightening scenario, based on an anxiety hierarchy created by the patient, and moves progressively to more challenging situations. This methodical progression allows the patient to develop coping skills and confidence at each level before advancing, minimising the risk of overwhelming anxiety. Additionally, systematic desensitisation often incorporates imaginary exposure before moving to real-life scenarios, allowing for a more controlled and patient-friendly approach. This distinction makes systematic desensitisation particularly suitable for individuals with intense phobias who might not tolerate immediate full exposure.

Practice Questions

Describe the process of systematic desensitisation and explain how it is applied in treating fear-related disorders.

Systematic desensitisation is a behavioural therapy technique rooted in classical conditioning, primarily used for treating phobias. The process involves three key stages: relaxation training, creation of an anxiety hierarchy, and controlled exposure. Initially, patients learn relaxation techniques, such as deep breathing or progressive muscle relaxation, to alleviate anxiety. Next, an anxiety hierarchy is constructed, listing feared situations in ascending order of anxiety intensity. Finally, patients are gradually exposed to these fears, starting from the least anxiety-provoking. This exposure is combined with relaxation exercises. Over time, this leads to a reduction in the fear response, as patients learn to associate relaxation with the feared stimulus, effectively treating the fear-related disorder. The therapy's success depends on a controlled and systematic approach, emphasising patient safety and comfort.

Evaluate the effectiveness of behavioural therapies in treating anxiety disorders. Discuss at least two factors that influence their effectiveness.

Behavioural therapies, including systematic desensitisation, are highly effective in treating anxiety disorders, particularly specific phobias. Their success lies in targeting the behavioural aspects of the disorder, providing long-term relief compared to pharmacotherapy. However, their effectiveness is influenced by factors like patient engagement and therapist expertise. Active participation and commitment from the patient are crucial, as the therapy requires consistent practice and adherence to the treatment plan. Additionally, the therapist's skill and experience significantly impact the therapy's success; a knowledgeable therapist can tailor the therapy to the individual's needs and adjust the approach based on progress. While effective, these therapies are not universally successful for all types of anxiety disorders and may be less effective for complex or deeply ingrained fears.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
About yourself
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email