TutorChase logo
AQA A-Level Psychology Notes

1.5.1 Resistance to Social Influence: Social Support

Understanding the dynamics of social support is crucial in exploring how individuals resist social influence. This concept highlights the impact of peers and social networks in empowering individuals to challenge conformity and obedience.

The Essence of Social Support

Social support is a multifaceted concept that enables individuals to withstand social pressures, often exerted by the majority or authority figures.

Types of Social Support

  • Emotional Support: This involves the presence of empathetic and understanding individuals who share similar non-conformist views. Such emotional backing gives individuals the courage to resist societal norms.
  • Informational Support: Knowledge sharing about non-conformity or disobedience instances equips individuals with evidence and confidence that resistance is feasible and sometimes necessary.
  • Instrumental Support: Practical help or resources provided by others can aid in resisting social pressures.

Pivotal Studies Illustrating Social Support

Solomon Asch (1951) - Conformity Studies

  • Experiment Details: Asch's experiment involved groups where most participants (confederates) intentionally gave incorrect answers to simple visual perception tasks.
  • Key Findings: Participants conformed less frequently when at least one confederate dissented, even if they gave a different incorrect answer.
  • Psychological Insight: This demonstrates the power of dissent in reducing conformity, even if the dissent is not entirely accurate.

Stanley Milgram (1963) - Obedience Studies

  • Experiment Overview: Milgram's study aimed to assess obedience to authority figures by instructing participants to administer electric shocks to a learner.
  • Critical Observations: When a fellow teacher (confederate) refused to comply, participants were more likely to stop administering shocks.
  • Psychological Relevance: This illustrates how resistance from peers can significantly diminish obedience to authority, even in stressful situations.

Theoretical Perspectives on Social Support

Social Impact Theory (Latane, 1981)

  • Theory Overview: The theory proposes that social influence is contingent upon the strength, immediacy, and number of influence sources.
  • Relevance to Social Support: The presence of dissenting individuals can substantially reduce the social impact of conforming pressures.

Social Learning Theory (Bandura, 1977)

  • Fundamental Concept: Bandura's theory highlights learning through observation of others' behaviours and the consequences they face.
  • Relation to Resistance: Observing others successfully resisting social pressures can serve as a learning experience, promoting similar behaviours in observers.

Factors Affecting Social Support’s Influence

Unanimity and Dissent

  • Importance of Non-Unanimity: The presence of even one dissenting voice in a group can significantly reduce conformity.
  • Psychological Mechanism: Dissent disrupts the unanimity, making individuals feel less compelled to follow the majority.

Credibility and Similarity

  • Influence of Credibility: Support from credible individuals, such as experts or respected figures, is more influential in resisting social pressures.
  • Role of Similarity: Individuals are more inclined to resist conformity when supported by people they perceive as similar to themselves in some significant way.

The Impact of Social Support on Psychological Resilience

Building Self-Efficacy

  • Self-Efficacy and Resistance: Witnessing others resist boosts one's belief in their ability to resist, thus enhancing psychological resilience against social pressures.
  • Empirical Support: Research shows a positive correlation between observed resistance and increased self-efficacy.

Role Modeling

  • Behavioral Modeling: People who resist provide a practical model for others, demonstrating how to oppose undue influence.
  • Impact on Autonomy: This encourages independent thinking and action, fostering a sense of autonomy and resistance to external pressures.

Emotional and Cognitive Empowerment

  • Emotional Support: Encouragement and empathy from others can reduce fear and anxiety associated with non-conformity.
  • Cognitive Reappraisal: Interaction with supportive peers can help reframe the situation, enabling individuals to view resistance as a viable and positive option.

Conclusion: The Power of Social Support

In conclusion, social support emerges as a key factor in an individual's ability to resist social influence. Through a combination of emotional, informational, and instrumental support, individuals find the strength to defy conformity and obedience. Studies by Asch and Milgram, along with theories like Social Impact Theory and Social Learning Theory, underscore the significance of peer influence in shaping resistance behaviours. The dynamics of unanimity, credibility, similarity, self-efficacy, role modeling, and emotional and cognitive empowerment play integral roles in this process. Understanding these elements provides invaluable insights into the psychological mechanisms behind social resistance, highlighting the profound impact of social support systems in our lives.

FAQ

Minority influence, a concept in social psychology, relates closely to the role of social support in resisting social influence. It refers to the ability of a small group or an individual (the minority) to influence the beliefs or behaviors of the larger group (the majority). This influence is particularly relevant in the context of resisting conformity and obedience. A minority that remains consistent, confident, and unwavering in its stance can exert a disproportionate influence on the majority. This process occurs through a re-evaluation of the majority's perspectives, prompted by the minority's different views. Social support from a minority group can provide individuals with alternative viewpoints and strategies for resistance, challenging the status quo and encouraging independent thought. The presence of a confident and consistent minority can inspire others to reconsider their conformist positions and potentially adopt the minority's viewpoint, thereby resisting the prevailing social influence. This demonstrates the power of a committed and cohesive minority in shaping attitudes and behaviors within a group, emphasizing the role of social support in facilitating resistance to social norms and authority.

Yes, the type of social support – emotional, informational, or instrumental – can significantly influence the degree of resistance to social influence. Emotional support, such as empathy and understanding from peers, can bolster an individual’s confidence and reduce the fear associated with going against the norm. This type of support is crucial in situations where social rejection or isolation is a concern. Informational support, which includes sharing knowledge and evidence that resistance is possible, can enlighten individuals about their choices and the potential outcomes of resisting. It helps in breaking down the perceived invincibility of conformist pressures. Instrumental support, involving practical assistance or resources, can be particularly effective in situations where specific actions or resources are required to resist. For example, having access to alternative sources of information or a safe space to discuss non-conformist ideas can greatly enhance an individual's capacity to resist. The effectiveness of each type of support can vary depending on the context and the individual’s personal needs and circumstances. In many cases, a combination of all three types of support can provide the most robust foundation for resisting social influence.

The presence of a supportive group in high-pressure situations can significantly enhance an individual's ability to resist conformity. This support provides a sense of safety and validation, reducing the fear of negative consequences often associated with non-conformity. In such scenarios, individuals are not only influenced by the mere presence of others who share their views but also derive confidence from the group's collective strength. The group acts as a psychological shield, offering reassurance and emotional comfort, which helps mitigate the stress and anxiety that typically accompany high-pressure situations. This collective resilience emboldens individuals, making it easier for them to maintain their stance against conformist pressures. Additionally, the group can offer alternative perspectives and strategies for resistance, further empowering the individual. This dynamic is particularly vital in scenarios where the pressure to conform is intense, and the stakes are high, as it provides a counterbalance to the dominant influence exerted by the majority or authority figures.

The perceived similarity between an individual and their supportive group plays a significant role in resisting social influence. When individuals perceive their supporters as similar to themselves, whether in terms of beliefs, values, experiences, or characteristics, it strengthens the impact of the support. This similarity fosters a stronger sense of identification with the group, enhancing the influence and credibility of the support provided. Individuals are more likely to be persuaded and feel empowered by those they perceive as similar to themselves, as it creates a sense of shared experience and mutual understanding. This shared identity can increase the confidence of the individual in their ability to resist, as they see their own views and feelings reflected and validated by the group. Furthermore, similarity can also facilitate stronger emotional connections, making the support more personally meaningful and effective. This dynamic is particularly important in contexts where social influence is strong, as the sense of belonging to a similar group can provide a powerful counterbalance to the pressures of conformity and obedience.

The concept of social support is integral to understanding the psychology of group dynamics and individual behavior within groups. Social support within a group context influences how individuals perceive, interact with, and respond to group norms and pressures. It plays a critical role in shaping group cohesion, morale, and collective resilience. When individuals receive support from their group, they are more likely to feel valued, understood, and connected, which enhances group harmony and stability. This supportive environment fosters open communication, allowing for the exchange of diverse ideas and perspectives, and encourages members to express dissenting opinions without fear of exclusion or ridicule. In terms of individual behavior, the presence of social support within a group can empower members to resist conformist pressures, maintain their autonomy, and make decisions that align with their personal values and beliefs, even in the face of strong group norms or authoritative demands. This dynamic highlights the importance of supportive relationships in moderating the influence of the group on individual behavior, demonstrating how social support can act as a buffer against undue conformity and promote psychological well-being and independence within group settings.

Practice Questions

Evaluate the role of social support in reducing conformity, referencing Asch’s conformity studies.

Social support plays a crucial role in reducing conformity, as evidenced by Asch’s conformity studies. Asch found that the presence of just one dissenter in a group, who gave correct answers, significantly decreased conformity rates among participants. This illustrates the power of social support in providing individuals with the courage to resist majority influence. Social support acts as a psychological buffer, reducing the fear of social disapproval and increasing the individual's confidence in their non-conformist stance. It demonstrates the importance of dissenting voices in promoting independent thinking and resistance to undue social pressures.

Discuss the impact of social support in Stanley Milgram’s obedience studies and its implications for understanding resistance to authority.

In Stanley Milgram’s obedience studies, social support significantly impacted participants' willingness to obey authority figures. When participants were accompanied by individuals who refused to administer shocks, obedience rates dramatically decreased. This finding underlines the importance of social support in resisting authority. It suggests that the presence of dissenting peers provides a model of resistance, challenging the normative influence of authority and empowering individuals to act according to their moral compass. The study demonstrates that social support can break the perceived obligation to obey authority, highlighting its crucial role in fostering autonomous decision-making and ethical resistance.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
Your details
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email