TutorChase logo
AQA A-Level Psychology Notes

1.1.3 Compliance in Conformity

Compliance, a significant aspect of social psychology, is a type of conformity where individuals outwardly follow group norms but inwardly disagree. This superficial adaptation is primarily influenced by social pressures and the desire to fit into a group, making it temporary and situational. It contrasts markedly with internalisation and identification, where beliefs and attitudes undergo deeper changes.

Understanding Compliance

Nature of Compliance

  • Superficial Adaptation: Compliance involves changing one's behaviour to align with a group while maintaining personal beliefs.
  • Short-term Change: These changes are temporary, often reverting back when the group influence is removed.
  • Driven by Social Pressure: Compliance is mainly influenced by the need to conform to immediate social expectations.

Characteristics

  • External vs Internal: Individuals in compliance show an external change that doesn’t reflect their internal views.
  • Situational Dependence: The extent of compliance can vary depending on the situation or context.
  • Lack of Personal Commitment: There is no genuine acceptance of the group's norms or beliefs.

Factors Influencing Compliance

Social Influences

  • Group Dynamics: Larger groups and unanimous opinions exert more pressure, leading to higher compliance.
  • Authority and Power: The presence and directives of authority figures can significantly increase compliance levels.

Individual Dispositions

  • Social Approval: The need for acceptance or fear of rejection can drive individuals to comply.
  • Self-Confidence and Self-Esteem: Those with lower self-confidence or self-esteem are more likely to comply to avoid conflict.

Situational Context

  • Uncertainty: In ambiguous situations, individuals are more likely to follow group consensus.
  • Visibility of Behaviour: Public settings, where actions are visible to others, tend to elicit more compliance than private settings.

Compliance vs Internalisation and Identification

Comparison with Internalisation

  • Depth of Change: Internalisation involves a deep-seated change in beliefs and values, unlike the superficial nature of compliance.
  • Longevity: Changes from internalisation are enduring and persist outside the group context, unlike the temporary nature of compliance.

Comparison with Identification

  • Role Adoption: In identification, individuals assume roles and their associated behaviours, which may have a more profound impact than the mere outward agreement seen in compliance.
  • Effect on Identity: Identification can alter one's self-concept and identity, whereas compliance does not have such a deep influence.

Real-World Examples

Consumer Behaviour

  • Trend Following: People often buy popular products to fit in with peers, even if they do not personally like them.
  • Advertising Influence: Compliance is frequently seen in consumer responses to persuasive advertising, where social cues and authority endorsements lead to temporary changes in purchasing behaviour.

Workplace Dynamics

  • Agreeing with Management: Employees might outwardly support a company policy in meetings but privately disagree.
  • Team Projects: Individuals may go along with team decisions for the sake of harmony, despite personal reservations.

Theoretical Perspectives

Solomon Asch’s Conformity Experiments

  • Asch's Line Experiment: This experiment illustrated how individuals conformed to incorrect group opinions about line lengths.
  • Insights on Compliance: It highlighted the impact of group pressure on individual judgment, epitomising compliance.

Stanley Milgram’s Obedience Studies

  • Obedience to Authority: These studies demonstrated how individuals would follow authority commands, even when they conflicted with personal morals, showcasing extreme forms of compliance.

The Bystander Effect

  • Diffusion of Responsibility: This phenomenon explains how individuals in a group are less likely to take action in an emergency, often complying with the group’s inaction.

Implications of Compliance

Social Harmony

  • Facilitates Group Functioning: Compliance can aid in the smooth functioning of groups by reducing conflict and maintaining social harmony.

Personal and Social Consequences

  • Stress and Dissonance: Continuous compliance can lead to internal stress and cognitive dissonance.
  • Influence on Decision Making: In settings like juries or committees, compliance can significantly affect decision outcomes.

Understanding Social Influence

  • Insight into Group Dynamics: Studying compliance provides valuable insights into how groups can influence individual behaviour.
  • Applications in Marketing and Leadership: Understanding compliance is crucial in fields like marketing, where social influence is a key tool, and in leadership, where it affects team dynamics.

Compliance, as a form of conformity, reveals the complexities of social influence and group dynamics. It highlights how individuals often balance their desire for group acceptance against their personal beliefs and values. For students of AQA A-Level Psychology, understanding these nuances is essential for grasping the broader concepts of social psychology and human behaviour.

FAQ

Gender can influence the likelihood and nature of compliance, although these effects are complex and multifaceted. Research suggests that women are generally more likely to comply than men, especially in situations that involve social harmony and interpersonal relationships. This tendency can be attributed to traditional gender roles and socialisation, where women are often encouraged to be cooperative, nurturing, and to value group harmony. However, this is not a universal rule and can vary depending on the context and the specific nature of the compliance. For example, in professional settings or situations involving moral judgments, women may be less likely to comply if it conflicts with their principles or professional integrity. On the other hand, men may exhibit higher compliance in situations where hierarchy and authority are involved, aligning with traditional male socialisation that emphasises respect for authority and leadership. It's important to note that these tendencies are influenced by cultural norms and societal expectations and are subject to change as gender roles evolve.

Compliance manifests differently in individualistic and collectivistic cultures due to varying societal values and norms. In individualistic cultures, where independence and personal autonomy are highly valued, compliance might be less prevalent or more covert, as overt conformity can be seen as a loss of individuality. People in these cultures might comply in situations where they seek to avoid conflict or gain social approval, but they may also be more willing to express dissent or maintain personal beliefs in the face of group pressure. In contrast, in collectivistic cultures, where harmony and group cohesion are prioritised, compliance is often more openly accepted and even encouraged. The emphasis on group consensus and maintaining social harmony means individuals in these cultures are more likely to outwardly conform to group norms, even if these conflict with personal beliefs. Additionally, the consequences of non-compliance, such as social ostracism or disapproval, can be more severe in collectivistic cultures, further incentivising compliance. Understanding these cultural differences is crucial in global and multicultural contexts, as it affects interpersonal interactions, business practices, and educational approaches.

The online environment significantly affects compliance behaviour, mainly due to the nature of digital interactions and the presence of virtual communities. Online, individuals are often part of multiple groups with varying norms and expectations, which can lead to different levels of compliance. The anonymity and distance provided by the online medium can sometimes reduce the pressure to comply, as individuals may feel less directly accountable to the group. However, in other instances, especially in tightly-knit online communities or social media platforms, the pressure to conform can be intense. Here, compliance may be driven by the desire for acceptance, fear of public criticism, or the influence of digital "authority" figures like influencers or popular users. Additionally, the rapid spread of information and opinions online can create a bandwagon effect, where individuals quickly align with the dominant viewpoint, demonstrating a form of digital compliance. Understanding compliance in the online realm is particularly relevant in the context of internet culture, marketing strategies, and the spread of misinformation.

While compliance is fundamentally a temporary and superficial form of conformity, under certain circumstances, it can lead to longer-term behavioural changes. This is particularly true when compliance occurs repeatedly over an extended period, creating a habit or norm of behaviour. For example, if an individual consistently complies with a group's norms, over time, these behaviours can become more ingrained and habitual, even in the absence of immediate group pressure. Additionally, consistent compliance might lead to a gradual shift in an individual's attitudes or beliefs, especially if the compliant behaviours are rewarded or positively reinforced. This phenomenon can be explained by cognitive dissonance theory, which suggests that when there is a discrepancy between one's actions and beliefs, an individual might change their beliefs to align with their actions to reduce psychological discomfort. However, it is important to note that this kind of longer-term change is more an exception than the rule in compliance and usually requires specific conditions, such as continuous reinforcement or lack of conflicting internal beliefs.

Compliance is particularly relevant in the context of peer pressure among adolescents. During adolescence, the influence of peers significantly increases, often shaping behaviour and choices. Compliance in this age group is driven by the intense desire to fit in and be accepted by one's peers, which can lead to conforming to behaviours or attitudes that align with the group, even when these are in conflict with personal beliefs or values. This phenomenon is evident in various scenarios, such as adopting certain fashion trends, engaging in risky behaviours, or conforming to group opinions on social and cultural matters. The temporary and superficial nature of compliance is highlighted in adolescence, as young individuals might frequently change their outward behaviours to align with different peer groups, depending on the social context. This age group is also a critical period for identity formation, making the impact of compliance on personal development and self-esteem more pronounced. Understanding the dynamics of compliance in peer pressure can help in addressing issues like bullying, substance abuse, and the development of critical thinking skills among adolescents.

Practice Questions

Describe the concept of compliance within the context of social conformity. Explain two factors that can influence an individual's likelihood to comply.

Compliance refers to the superficial and temporary change in behaviour or attitudes to align with a group, while internally maintaining different views. This type of conformity is driven by external pressures rather than genuine belief alignment. One factor influencing compliance is the presence of authority figures; individuals often comply more readily when instructions or norms are endorsed by an authority. Another influential factor is the desire for social acceptance. People are more inclined to comply with group norms to avoid rejection or to gain approval, especially in situations where their actions are publicly visible.

Contrast compliance with internalisation and identification as forms of conformity.

Compliance, internalisation, and identification represent different depths of conformity. Compliance is superficial and temporary; individuals outwardly conform to group norms but retain their internal beliefs, often due to social pressure or the desire for group acceptance. In contrast, internalisation is the deepest form of conformity, where individuals genuinely adopt the group's beliefs and values, leading to permanent changes in behaviour and attitudes. Identification lies between these two; it involves adopting behaviours and attitudes to fit a desired social role, influencing self-perception but not necessarily involving a deep change in personal beliefs like in internalisation.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
About yourself
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email