TutorChase logo
CIE A-Level Business Studies Notes

7.4.1 HRM Strategy: HRM Approaches

'Hard' vs 'Soft' HRM

'Hard' HRM is a strategic approach focusing on the workforce primarily as a resource for achieving business objectives. It is characterised by its emphasis on the quantitative, calculative, and business-strategic aspects of managing human resources.

  • Characteristics:
    • Cost minimisation focus.
    • Emphasis on workforce planning, and tight control.
    • Limited employee participation in decision-making.

In contrast, 'Soft' HRM is oriented towards valuing employees as vital assets of an organisation, with a focus on mutual goals, motivation, and importance of the workforce.

  • Characteristics:
    • Focus on employee development and well-being.
    • Encourages open communication and employee involvement in decision-making.
    • Views employees as capable of development and worthy of trust and collaboration.
A table comparing hard HRM with soft HRM.

Image courtesy of slideplayer

Flexible Working Contracts

Flexible working contracts offer different arrangements to cater to varying employee needs and organisational demands.

  • Types:
    • Part-time Contracts: Employees work fewer hours than the standard full-time hours, providing flexibility and work-life balance.
    • Flexitime Contracts: Employees have the freedom to choose their working hours within certain agreed limits, promoting autonomy.
    • Zero Hours Contracts: Offer no guaranteed hours, providing ultimate flexibility but less job security.
A bar chart illustrating flexible working contracts in the UK in 2023

Image courtesy of statista

Measuring Employee Performance

Effective performance measurement is key to assessing and improving employee productivity and efficiency.

  • Methods:
    • KPIs (Key Performance Indicators): Specific, measurable metrics that reflect critical success factors of an organisation.
    • 360-Degree Feedback: Involves feedback from a full circle of people, including managers, peers, subordinates, and sometimes customers.
A diagram illustrating 360 degree feedback

Image courtesy of factohr

Causes and Consequences of Poor Employee Performance

Poor employee performance can stem from various factors and leads to significant negative impacts on the business.

  • Causes: Inadequate training, unclear job roles, personal issues, lack of motivation, inadequate resources.
  • Consequences: Reduced overall productivity, diminished employee morale, increased staff turnover, negative impact on organisational culture.

Strategies for Performance Improvement

Effective strategies are needed to address performance issues and enhance employee capabilities.

  • Training and Development: Tailored programmes to improve skills and competencies.
  • Performance Appraisals: Regular, structured discussions about performance and goals.
  • Reward Systems: Both financial and non-financial rewards to recognise and encourage high performance.

Management by Objectives (MBO)

MBO is a strategic approach that aligns the performance of individual employees with the overall objectives of the organisation.

  • Process:
    • Defining clear, specific organisational objectives.
    • Cascading these objectives down to employees at all levels.
    • Regular monitoring and assessment of performance against these objectives.
A table illustrating advantages and disadvantages of management by objectives (MBO)

Image courtesy of geeksforgeeks

Role of IT and AI in HRM

The integration of Information Technology (IT) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) in HRM is revolutionising the way organisations manage their human resources.

  • Applications:
    • Recruitment: AI-powered algorithms to screen and shortlist candidates, enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the recruitment process.
    • Training: Utilisation of e-learning platforms and virtual reality simulations for more engaging and effective training experiences.
    • Data Analysis: Advanced IT systems for tracking, storing, and analysing employee data, aiding in strategic decision-making.

By comprehensively understanding these HRM approaches, organisations can more effectively manage their workforce, aligning employee performance with strategic business objectives. For A-Level Business Studies students, a deep understanding of these concepts is essential for appreciating the complexities and significance of human resource management in the business world.

FAQ

While flexible working contracts offer many benefits, they also present several potential drawbacks for businesses. One major challenge is managing communication and coordination. With employees working varying hours or remotely, ensuring effective communication and coordination of tasks can be challenging. This can lead to inefficiencies and delays if not managed properly. Another issue is the potential impact on team dynamics and workplace culture. The reduced physical presence of employees can hinder the development of strong team relationships and a cohesive culture, which are critical for collaboration and innovation. There's also the risk of some employees feeling isolated or disconnected from the organisation. Furthermore, managing performance can be more complex with flexible working arrangements, as traditional methods of performance evaluation may not be suitable. Businesses need to develop new strategies to assess and manage performance effectively under these conditions. Lastly, there's a potential for inconsistency in workloads and a perception of unfairness among employees, which can lead to resentment and a decline in morale.

Management by Objectives (MBO) aligns well with contemporary HRM strategies, particularly those focusing on employee empowerment, goal alignment, and performance management. MBO involves setting specific, measurable goals with each employee and then periodically reviewing the progress made. This approach aligns employee objectives with the company's goals, ensuring a direct connection between individual performance and the overall success of the organisation. MBO also promotes employee engagement and motivation, as employees are involved in setting their own goals and are therefore more committed to achieving them. This participative approach is in line with contemporary HRM strategies that emphasise employee involvement, development, and recognition. Moreover, MBO aids in performance appraisal processes, providing a clear, objective basis for evaluating employee performance, facilitating fair and constructive feedback, and identifying areas for development. As HRM continues to evolve with a focus on strategic alignment and employee engagement, MBO remains a relevant and valuable tool.

The use of IT and AI in HRM plays a pivotal role in supporting strategic decision-making in organisations. These technologies enable the collection, analysis, and interpretation of vast amounts of data, which can inform a wide range of strategic decisions. For example, AI can analyse employee performance data to identify trends, strengths, and areas for improvement, guiding decisions on training needs, workforce planning, and talent management. Additionally, AI-driven predictive analytics can forecast future HR needs, helping in strategic planning and proactive decision-making. AI can also enhance talent acquisition strategies by identifying the best candidates for open positions, reducing recruitment costs and time. Furthermore, IT systems streamline HR processes, such as payroll and benefits administration, allowing HR professionals to focus more on strategic tasks. By providing insights derived from data, IT and AI not only improve the efficiency of HR operations but also contribute significantly to formulating and executing business strategies, ensuring that the human capital aligns with the organisation's long-term goals.

The implementation of AI in HRM, especially in recruitment and performance management, raises significant ethical considerations. One major concern is the potential for inherent bias in AI algorithms. If the data used to train AI systems is biased, the AI's decisions can perpetuate and even amplify these biases, leading to unfair treatment of certain groups of candidates or employees. This could include gender, racial, or age biases. Transparency and accountability in AI decision-making are also crucial. It's important for organisations to ensure that AI-driven decisions can be explained and justified, maintaining human oversight in critical HR processes. Privacy is another major concern, as AI systems often handle sensitive employee data. Organisations must ensure robust data protection measures to safeguard this information and comply with legal standards. Finally, there's the human impact - replacing human interaction with AI in HR processes can be dehumanising, and organisations must balance efficiency gains with maintaining a personal touch in employee relations.

Flexible working contracts, when implemented effectively, can have a profound positive impact on organisational culture and employee morale. These contracts, which include part-time, flexitime, and zero hours arrangements, provide employees with greater control over their work-life balance. This autonomy can lead to increased job satisfaction, as employees feel valued and trusted to manage their own time. In turn, a positive organisational culture is fostered, characterised by trust, flexibility, and mutual respect. This culture often results in higher employee morale, reduced stress levels, and improved mental well-being. However, it's crucial for organisations to maintain clear communication and ensure that such flexibility doesn't lead to ambiguity in roles or responsibilities. Effective implementation requires a supportive management structure and a strong organisational framework that values employee well-being and recognises the diverse needs of its workforce.

Practice Questions

Explain the difference between 'hard' and 'soft' HRM approaches. Which approach do you think is more effective in a rapidly changing business environment? Justify your answer.

Hard HRM focuses on the workforce as a resource, emphasising cost-effectiveness and efficiency. It's quantitative and strategic, with limited employee involvement in decision-making. In contrast, Soft HRM values employees as assets, promoting their development, welfare, and involvement in decision-making. In a rapidly changing business environment, Soft HRM is more effective. It fosters adaptability and innovation by encouraging employee engagement and creativity. Soft HRM's emphasis on communication and collaboration helps businesses respond quickly to changes, as employees are more aligned with the organisation's goals and more motivated to contribute to its success.

Discuss how the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in HRM can improve employee performance management. Provide an example.

The integration of AI in HRM significantly enhances performance management. AI can analyse vast amounts of data to provide insights into employee performance, identifying areas for improvement. For example, AI algorithms can track productivity patterns and suggest personalised training or development programmes. This ensures that interventions are data-driven and tailored to individual needs, leading to more effective performance improvements. AI can also automate routine tasks like performance tracking, freeing HR professionals to focus on strategic aspects like employee engagement and development. This increased efficiency and personalisation in performance management directly contributes to better employee performance and overall organisational efficiency.

Hire a tutor

Please fill out the form and we'll find a tutor for you.

1/2
About yourself
Alternatively contact us via
WhatsApp, Phone Call, or Email